Jan
18

“Aiki Principles, are they realistic?,” by Francis Takahashi

Are the Aiki Principles, the exalted foundation for the Founder’s Aikido, and the very same ones which his direct followers claimed to have formed the structure and rationale for his Aikido, realistically based on a workable theory that we can implement, or merely a fanciful construct of ideals that we can only wish were attainable? Are we merely justifying a fantasy, a magnificently romantic notion, that the citizens of this world can truly understand and apply such standards of excellence to everyday life, to personal mastery, and to harmony worldwide? What proofs do we have that verify the actual existence and implementation of these most laudable characteristics in the makeup of mankind as we know it to be?

Perhaps we can view the Founder’s adoption of “Aiki Principles” in the same fashion that we would view the notion of “world peace”, or of “equality amongst men”, both extremely popular and desirable concepts, but having pragmatically no chance of becoming reality. Perhaps it is enough to merely state such dreams and hopes for some utopian future, when such notions may truly become reality, and where the destiny for mankind finally comes into its harmonious fruition.

As rather utopian ideals, is it wrong to want to employ Aiki Principles to then construct a feel good philosophy, an ongoing “work in progress” for the affording of happiness to the common folk, and a truly human vehicle to help bridge the chasms that obstruct the way to positive and open communication, natural exchanges of courtesy, and the much needed methods of simply getting along with one another? Even so, wouldn’t this be so much better and universally desirable to using drugs, consuming alcohol, and foisting fanciful schemes to benefit one class of people at the expense of another?

Granted, each proponent of the Aiki Principles, and/or of the Founder’s Aikido, is free to associate any rationale for one’s core beliefs, and owes nothing in terms of an explanation or proof of correctness for that decision. It should, and rightfully does remain an intensely personal and private identity of self for each person, and to be respected as such by anyone else.

I, for one, never took seriously the naïve claims by some that the Aiki Principles were actually a panacea for the world’s ills, that they possessed any pragmatic and tested solutions for achieving and preserving “world peace”, that “good men and women” would actually band together one fine day to make a better world come true, simply by stating, believing and proselytizing such otherwise noble notions of hope and faith. The banishment of “fighting”, “combat”, and of the existence of conflict itself, appeared grossly fanciful, and even injurious to those who blithely believed that such notions ensured their safety and sanity.

Charles Darwin’s meager efforts did not create the concept of natural selection, but served to shed the light of reason on the paradigm shifting consequences of accepting the evidence that kept on growing so exponentially.

So too, did the Founder of Aikido merely point out another way of viewing and appreciating the immense significance of traditional Budo, and daring to view the ability to merely “fight” effectively as secondary or less, to a much higher purpose. This purpose, in part, was to reinterprete the principles of traditional Budo, into discovering and implementing alternative ways of achieving survival, and to win the day without resorting to conflict as the first response.

Aikido Founder Morihei Ueshiba (1883-1969)

No, Aikido does not provide an easy formula to utilize. It appears to give rather simplistic and innocently naïve answers to tough questions regarding effective conflict resolution. It further appears to base its proof of legitimacy on the very act of actually living out those principles on a daily basis, much like a true believer on a religious mission. You either take it at face value, or you move on to other choices. You vote with your feet, not with your fists, and at some deep and personal level, you truly hope that you are right.

In reading the translated words of the Founder on such matters, I cannot help but wonder what, and to what extent, poetic license was taken in translating the Founder’s actual meaning and purpose, for the utterances and writings attributed to him. History seems replete with second hand accounts that, over time and rewritings, scarcely resemble or even echo the primary sentiments and intent of the original author or authors. It is simply way too much to ask fallible humans to recount or preserve intact the offerings from persons who themselves were admittedly imperfect and fallible to begin with.

For me, the main draw from the beginning of my consciousness of why I really did want to continue my association with Aikido, and with its uniquely optimistic proponents, was for the very wonderful relationships I was honored and privileged to develop. The magnificence, generosity, unparalleled insight, and plain goodness of the special people I have met more than makes up for any real or perceived lack of proof that the Aiki Principles and the ideals of Aikido training are worth the effort, or appropriate for my lifelong commitment. I am in all the way.

As a feeble, fallible and flawed individual myself, it is enough for me to simply take at face value the Aiki Principles as I believe the Founder intended, and to allow my inner sensei to do the heavy lifting of applying those parts that make sense, and to respectfully disregard and discard the rest. I believe that some call this “shugyo”, and the true rationale of why we train the way we choose.

The discussion regarding the efficacy and validity of Aikido training, and of its technical relevance, will have to wait for another time.

Click here to view the original article on Aikido Academy USA

Aikido Journal Members Site
For nearly 40 years, we have been researching and documenting every aspect of Aikido!
We hate spam just as much as you

Comments

  1. World peace and equality amongst men might have pragmatically no chance of becoming reality, but we should keep working as they could become reality, the mind power is great, we should keep thinking positive, if we think that there is not a chance, there sure isn’t it, but if we think there could be one, we might have a possibility. There is still hope, there are those wonderful relationships you developed, those special people you have met. So there are many, many people who are following “Aiki Principles”, whose training in Aiki made them better, maybe there are that much to convince others to do the same and together we could leave our children a better world.
    Thank you Takahashi Shihan for another thought-provoking, great article.

    You may find the translation in spanish here
    http://entrenandoaikido.blogspot.com/2011/10/los-principios-aiki-son-realistas.html
    and in german here
    http://wirtrainierenaikido.blogspot.com/2011/10/aiki-prinzipien-sind-sie-realistisch.html