Mar
12

From AJ forum: “On Kashima Shin-ryu and Aikido”

There is an interesting thread on the Aikido Journal forum of which the following is an excerpt on the relationship between Kashima Shin-ryu and aikido started by froggy that may be of interest to some readers:

Mr. Tissier’s swordwork derives from Kashima-Shinryu, via Inaba Minoru, the head Aikido instructor at the Meiji Grand Shrine in Tokyo. It is NOT, however, Kashima-Shinryu–in either a formal or a practical sense.

Inaba has worked a bit of Kashima-Shinryu kenjutsu and some other weapon training into his aikido curriculum at the Meiji Grand Shrine. Neither he nor his teacher, Tanaka Shigeo, however, has any formal connections with the current Kashima-Shinryu soke or shihanke, and neither has any Kashima-Shinryu license or diploma from either Kunii Zen’ya (the previous soke/shihanke) or Seki Humitake (the current shihanke; Inaba has a diploma written by Kunii, but unsigned, which he received from Kunii’s widow).

The Inaba connection with KSR began when Tanaka wished to learn Kashima Shinryu from Kunii, because he was teaching Aikido at the University of Tokyo, and his students were becoming discouraged by their inability to hold their own in friendly matches with the karate club students, who practiced at the same time. Determining that what his students needed was some weapons training, he went to Kunii to learn kenjutsu. But, as he was already 40 at the time, he found he was not learning well, and so he brought one of his senior students, Inaba, at the time an undergraduate university student, to study with Kunii as well.

Inaba studied KSR for less than a year, and never received any official diploma from Kunii Zen’ya, from Seki, or from the Kashima-Shinryu Federation of Martial Sciences, but he did, at the request of Kunii’s widow, receive permission to teach kenjutsu (but NOT other weapons; he had never actually trained at any KSR weapons other than the sword) at the dojo of the Meiji Grand Shrine. Sometime after Kunii’s death in 1966, one of Inaba’s supervisors asked Mrs. Kunii for permission for him to not recognize Aikido as proper martial training for shrine attendants, because it lacks any form of *harai* (exorcism). Under the circumstances, it was the permission granted Inaba extends only to the teaching of fundamental kenjutsu techniques, because his period of training was far too short to
learn and understand the arcana of Kashima-Shinryu. He has no authority to issue Kashima-Shinryu diplomas, nor does he have any right to use the name Kashima-Shinryu or to allow any of his students to use it. Thus Inaba’s formal status within Kashima-Shinryu is that of teaching fundamental kenjutsu techniques within the framework of teaching Aikido at the Meiji Grand Shrine dojo. His students and the students of his students, other than those teaching under him at the Meiji Grand Shrine dojo, have no formal relationship whatsoever to KSR.

Aikido and Kashima-Shinryu have elements in common, but they are really fundamentally different in strategy, philosophy and patterns of movement. (A rough analogy might be the differences and similarities between Islam and Christianity.) Inaba’s interpretation of KSR kata is heavily flavored by Aikido and thoroughly reshaped by minimal initial exposure to the real thing compounded by 3 decades of practicing in isolation. Many of the kata are unrecognizable to students of orthodox Kashima-Shinryu; most of the basic patterns and rhythms of movement and application of power are.

Mr. Tissier has been apprised of these facts, and has indicated that while he had been unaware of the situation, he will no longer call what he teaches KSR.

There are currently only two places in Europe (one group in Helsinki and one in Frankfurt) where legitimate KSR is taught under authorization by the current shihanke.

And at this URL you’ll find another post of K. Friday at http://listserv.uoguelph.ca/cgi-bin/wa?A2=ind0002&L=iaido-l&D=0&P=17884

Aikido Journal Members Site
For nearly 40 years, we have been researching and documenting every aspect of Aikido!
We hate spam just as much as you

Comments

  1. Robert Cowham says:

    It should be noted that Karl Friday’s comments above represent a perhaps slightly biased view of events – but then as a student of Inaba sensei I would say that :)

Speak Your Mind

*